Democracy Uprising
  • About
    • About Mark Engler
    • About Democracy Uprising
  • Books
    • This Is An Uprising
    • How To Rule the World
  • Topics
    • All Essays / First Person Global Economy Immigration Labor Latin America Social Movements Religion U.S. Politics / Elections War / Militarism Book Reviews Environment
      Social Movements

      Could we be entering a ‘movement moment’ against…

      Social Movements

      Trump’s backpedaling shows he’s not invincible

      Blog

      It’s going to take multiple strategies to win…

      2023-2025

      A new wave of movements against Trumpism is…

      Social Movements

      How to make sure your disruptive protest helps…

      Social Movements

      Why protests work, even when not everybody likes…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Harold Washington’s lessons for taking on a political…

      Social Movements

      Strategy is a Craft

      Essays / First Person

      Is Rambo Still A Republican?

      Essays / First Person

      On the Price is Right

      Essays / First Person

      The Last Porto Alegre

      Essays / First Person

      Six Essays About War and About Peace

      Essays / First Person

      Republicans Among Us

      Essays / First Person

      New York Says “No”

      Essays / First Person

      The Sideshow Rebels

      Essays / First Person

      A Week in New York

      Global Economy

      Meet the Bailout’s New Slush Fund for Corporate…

      Global Economy

      The Seattle Protests Showed That Another World Is…

      Global Economy

      Jeff Bezos Has Enough! It’s Time for a…

      Global Economy

      The Amazon Effect: Sweat, Surveillance, Exploitation

      Global Economy

      The Godfather of Microcredit

      Global Economy

      Capitalism as Catastrophe

      Global Economy

      Immigration Economics: An Interview with Professor Giovanni Peri

      Global Economy

      The World Is Not Flat

      Immigration

      When Undocumented Activists Infiltrated ICE

      Immigration

      The Children of Intervention

      Immigration

      Immigration Economics: An Interview with Professor Giovanni Peri

      Immigration

      Science Fiction From Below

      Immigration

      Four Ways of Looking at an Aztec Eagle

      Immigration

      Treated Like a Criminal

      Immigration

      When Sanctuary is Resistance

      Immigration

      The Massive Immigrants Rights Protests of 2006 Are…

      Labor

      This new model for upholding labor law may…

      Labor

      Democrats Won Power in Several States. Will They…

      Labor

      The Case for a Social Distancing Wage

      Labor

      The Seattle Protests Showed That Another World Is…

      Labor

      Reviving the General Strike

      Labor

      Jeff Bezos Has Enough! It’s Time for a…

      Labor

      There’s Still Power in a Strike

      Labor

      The Amazon Effect: Sweat, Surveillance, Exploitation

      Latin America

      How movements can maintain their radical vision while winning…

      Latin America

      The Pan American

      Latin America

      Lessons from the Pledge of Resistance

      Latin America

      The Children of Intervention

      Latin America

      Against Shithole Nationalism

      Latin America

      The Last Porto Alegre

      Latin America

      Kissinger Is Not Our Friend

      Latin America

      Even If You Have Nothing to Hide

      Social Movements

      Could we be entering a ‘movement moment’ against…

      Social Movements

      Trump’s backpedaling shows he’s not invincible

      Social Movements

      It’s going to take multiple strategies to win…

      Social Movements

      A new wave of movements against Trumpism is…

      Social Movements

      How to make sure your disruptive protest helps…

      Social Movements

      Why protests work, even when not everybody likes…

      Social Movements

      Harold Washington’s lessons for taking on a political…

      Social Movements

      Strategy is a Craft

      Religion

      In God’s Country

      Religion

      Reverend Billy’s Holiday Shopocalypse

      Religion

      Toward the “Rights of the Poor”

      Religion

      The Pope and the Poor

      Religion

      Will the Next Pope Embrace Liberation Theology?

      Religion

      Remembering Romero

      Religion

      John Paul II’s Economic Ethics

      Religion

      Against the God of Free Trade

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Could we be entering a ‘movement moment’ against…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Trump’s backpedaling shows he’s not invincible

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      It’s going to take multiple strategies to win…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      A new wave of movements against Trumpism is…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Harold Washington’s lessons for taking on a political…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Strategy is a Craft

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Think #MeToo didn’t make a real difference? Think…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      This new model for upholding labor law may…

      War / Militarism

      Does It Make Sense to Protest a President…

      War / Militarism

      Lessons from the Pledge of Resistance

      War / Militarism

      Is Rambo Still A Republican?

      War / Militarism

      War: The Wrong Jobs Program

      War / Militarism

      The Ascent of Niall Ferguson

      War / Militarism

      Those Who Don’t Count

      War / Militarism

      Six Essays About War and About Peace

      War / Militarism

      The Dangerous Dignity of War

      Book Reviews

      The Pan American

      Book Reviews

      The Godfather of Microcredit

      Book Reviews

      Capitalism as Catastrophe

      Book Reviews

      Four Ways of Looking at an Aztec Eagle

      Book Reviews

      The Ascent of Niall Ferguson

      Book Reviews

      Ordinary Outrages

      Book Reviews

      No Better Place

      Book Reviews

      In God’s Country

      Environment

      Why Wendell Matters

      Environment

      The Gulf at the Gas Station

      Environment

      Climate Disobedience

      Environment

      Farming the Everglades

      Environment

      The Winter of the Climate Denier

      Environment

      Climate of Change: An “Inside-Outside” Strategy Against Global…

      Environment

      Provoking an American Climate Crisis

      Environment

      The Real “Farmer” Story: So God Made High-Fructose…

  • Translations
    • All Deutsch Español Français Italiano Japanese Português Arabic Thai Chinese
      Translations

      Jordlösa kombinerar radikala visioner med praktiska reformer (Swedish)

      Español

      Hacer Que Nuestras Demandas Sean Tanto Orácticas Como…

      Italiano

      C’è più di un modo per colpire il…

      Português

      As reformas não reformistas de André Gorz mostram…

      Español

      Las reformas no reformistas de André Gorz

      Deutsch

      Die nicht-reformistischen Reformen von André Gorz

      Italiano

      Richieste dei movimenti: sia pratiche che visionarie

      Chinese

      泛美洲人 爱德华多·加莱亚诺的世界 (Chinese)

      Deutsch

      Die nicht-reformistischen Reformen von André Gorz

      Deutsch

      Als Martin Luther King seine Feuerwaffen aufgab

      Deutsch

      Mikrokredite: Die Entlassung eines Nobelpreisträgers

      Deutsch

      CAFTA – am besten stillschweigend beerdigen

      Deutsch

      Bush in Mexiko

      Deutsch

      Das globale Duell in Evian

      Deutsch

      Die Rückkehr des Daniel Ortega

      Español

      Hacer Que Nuestras Demandas Sean Tanto Orácticas Como…

      Español

      Las reformas no reformistas de André Gorz

      Español

      ¿Adoptará el nuevo papa la teología de la…

      Español

      Wall Street quiere que les estemos agradecidos

      Español

      Si Las Monjas Se Fueran a una Huelga,…

      Español

      ALEC retrocede; a la derecha le da un…

      Español

      ¿ALEC disgustado ante la pérdida de patrocinadores? Se…

      Español

      La vida en la nación prisión

      Français

      La révolution non-violente a-t-elle échoué en Egypte?

      Français

      Le pari risqué du populisme au Pérou

      Français

      Hong Kong Phooey

      Français

      Bush Nuit Même Aux Compagnies U.S.

      Français

      Le dynamisme du mouvement pour la paix

      Français

      La déroute de l’ALCA dans une Miami en…

      Français

      Ceux qui ne comptent pas

      Français

      La guerre en Irak : une expo des…

      Italiano

      C’è più di un modo per colpire il…

      Italiano

      Richieste dei movimenti: sia pratiche che visionarie

      Italiano

      La strategia di Gandhi per il successo –…

      Italiano

      Le promesse infrante di Obama

      Italiano

      Guantanamo deve sparire

      Italiano

      IL BANK TRANSFER DAY: UN SUCCESSO

      Italiano

      Come il movimento Occupiamo Wall Street si sta…

      Italiano

      Economia tabù

      Japanese

      ガンジーはどのように勝利したのか? (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Truth Versus Superpower (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Bush’s Bad Business Empire (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Revenge of the Combat Cartoonist (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Bush’s Uneasy Mexican Visita (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Mark Twain in Iraq (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Globalization’s “Lost Decade” (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Hawks Say the Damnedest Things (Japanese)

      Português

      As reformas não reformistas de André Gorz mostram…

      Português

      A vida na Nação Prisão

      Português

      Outro pretexto?

      Português

      Imigração tem efeito positivo sobre emprego e salários

      Português

      O império hipotecado

      Arabic

      Abandoning the World Bank (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      The Return of Daniel Ortega (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      Where’s The Jubilee? (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      The Last Porto Alegre (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      Seattle At Five (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      Is Market Access the Answer to Poverty? (in…

      Arabic

      Mexico’s Democratic Transition Still Incomplete (in Arabic)

      Thai

      Progressive Good Tidings of 2007 (in Thai)

      Thai

      2006: A Global Justice Year in Review (In…

      Thai

      WTO: Best Left For Dead? (In Thai)

      Thai

      Is Market Access the Answer to Poverty? (In…

      Thai

      Bush’s Bad Business Empire (In Thai)

      Thai

      The Last Porto Alegre [Thai]

      Thai

      Globalizers, Neocons, or… ? (in Thai)

      Chinese

      泛美洲人 爱德华多·加莱亚诺的世界 (Chinese)

      Chinese

      Why Wendell Matters (in Chinese)

      Chinese

      Globalization’s Watchdogs (in Chinese)

    • Other Translations
  • Appearances
  • Archive
    • 2023-2025
    • 2021-2022
    • 2019-2020
    • 2017-2018
    • 2015-2016
    • 2013-2014
    • 2011-2012
    • 2009-2010
    • 2007-2008
    • 2005-2006
    • 2003-2004
    • 1999-2002

Democracy Uprising

  • About
    • About Mark Engler
    • About Democracy Uprising
  • Books
    • This Is An Uprising
    • How To Rule the World
  • Topics
    • All Essays / First Person Global Economy Immigration Labor Latin America Social Movements Religion U.S. Politics / Elections War / Militarism Book Reviews Environment
      Social Movements

      Could we be entering a ‘movement moment’ against…

      Social Movements

      Trump’s backpedaling shows he’s not invincible

      Blog

      It’s going to take multiple strategies to win…

      2023-2025

      A new wave of movements against Trumpism is…

      Social Movements

      How to make sure your disruptive protest helps…

      Social Movements

      Why protests work, even when not everybody likes…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Harold Washington’s lessons for taking on a political…

      Social Movements

      Strategy is a Craft

      Essays / First Person

      Is Rambo Still A Republican?

      Essays / First Person

      On the Price is Right

      Essays / First Person

      The Last Porto Alegre

      Essays / First Person

      Six Essays About War and About Peace

      Essays / First Person

      Republicans Among Us

      Essays / First Person

      New York Says “No”

      Essays / First Person

      The Sideshow Rebels

      Essays / First Person

      A Week in New York

      Global Economy

      Meet the Bailout’s New Slush Fund for Corporate…

      Global Economy

      The Seattle Protests Showed That Another World Is…

      Global Economy

      Jeff Bezos Has Enough! It’s Time for a…

      Global Economy

      The Amazon Effect: Sweat, Surveillance, Exploitation

      Global Economy

      The Godfather of Microcredit

      Global Economy

      Capitalism as Catastrophe

      Global Economy

      Immigration Economics: An Interview with Professor Giovanni Peri

      Global Economy

      The World Is Not Flat

      Immigration

      When Undocumented Activists Infiltrated ICE

      Immigration

      The Children of Intervention

      Immigration

      Immigration Economics: An Interview with Professor Giovanni Peri

      Immigration

      Science Fiction From Below

      Immigration

      Four Ways of Looking at an Aztec Eagle

      Immigration

      Treated Like a Criminal

      Immigration

      When Sanctuary is Resistance

      Immigration

      The Massive Immigrants Rights Protests of 2006 Are…

      Labor

      This new model for upholding labor law may…

      Labor

      Democrats Won Power in Several States. Will They…

      Labor

      The Case for a Social Distancing Wage

      Labor

      The Seattle Protests Showed That Another World Is…

      Labor

      Reviving the General Strike

      Labor

      Jeff Bezos Has Enough! It’s Time for a…

      Labor

      There’s Still Power in a Strike

      Labor

      The Amazon Effect: Sweat, Surveillance, Exploitation

      Latin America

      How movements can maintain their radical vision while winning…

      Latin America

      The Pan American

      Latin America

      Lessons from the Pledge of Resistance

      Latin America

      The Children of Intervention

      Latin America

      Against Shithole Nationalism

      Latin America

      The Last Porto Alegre

      Latin America

      Kissinger Is Not Our Friend

      Latin America

      Even If You Have Nothing to Hide

      Social Movements

      Could we be entering a ‘movement moment’ against…

      Social Movements

      Trump’s backpedaling shows he’s not invincible

      Social Movements

      It’s going to take multiple strategies to win…

      Social Movements

      A new wave of movements against Trumpism is…

      Social Movements

      How to make sure your disruptive protest helps…

      Social Movements

      Why protests work, even when not everybody likes…

      Social Movements

      Harold Washington’s lessons for taking on a political…

      Social Movements

      Strategy is a Craft

      Religion

      In God’s Country

      Religion

      Reverend Billy’s Holiday Shopocalypse

      Religion

      Toward the “Rights of the Poor”

      Religion

      The Pope and the Poor

      Religion

      Will the Next Pope Embrace Liberation Theology?

      Religion

      Remembering Romero

      Religion

      John Paul II’s Economic Ethics

      Religion

      Against the God of Free Trade

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Could we be entering a ‘movement moment’ against…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Trump’s backpedaling shows he’s not invincible

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      It’s going to take multiple strategies to win…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      A new wave of movements against Trumpism is…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Harold Washington’s lessons for taking on a political…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Strategy is a Craft

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      Think #MeToo didn’t make a real difference? Think…

      U.S. Politics / Elections

      This new model for upholding labor law may…

      War / Militarism

      Does It Make Sense to Protest a President…

      War / Militarism

      Lessons from the Pledge of Resistance

      War / Militarism

      Is Rambo Still A Republican?

      War / Militarism

      War: The Wrong Jobs Program

      War / Militarism

      The Ascent of Niall Ferguson

      War / Militarism

      Those Who Don’t Count

      War / Militarism

      Six Essays About War and About Peace

      War / Militarism

      The Dangerous Dignity of War

      Book Reviews

      The Pan American

      Book Reviews

      The Godfather of Microcredit

      Book Reviews

      Capitalism as Catastrophe

      Book Reviews

      Four Ways of Looking at an Aztec Eagle

      Book Reviews

      The Ascent of Niall Ferguson

      Book Reviews

      Ordinary Outrages

      Book Reviews

      No Better Place

      Book Reviews

      In God’s Country

      Environment

      Why Wendell Matters

      Environment

      The Gulf at the Gas Station

      Environment

      Climate Disobedience

      Environment

      Farming the Everglades

      Environment

      The Winter of the Climate Denier

      Environment

      Climate of Change: An “Inside-Outside” Strategy Against Global…

      Environment

      Provoking an American Climate Crisis

      Environment

      The Real “Farmer” Story: So God Made High-Fructose…

  • Translations
    • All Deutsch Español Français Italiano Japanese Português Arabic Thai Chinese
      Translations

      Jordlösa kombinerar radikala visioner med praktiska reformer (Swedish)

      Español

      Hacer Que Nuestras Demandas Sean Tanto Orácticas Como…

      Italiano

      C’è più di un modo per colpire il…

      Português

      As reformas não reformistas de André Gorz mostram…

      Español

      Las reformas no reformistas de André Gorz

      Deutsch

      Die nicht-reformistischen Reformen von André Gorz

      Italiano

      Richieste dei movimenti: sia pratiche che visionarie

      Chinese

      泛美洲人 爱德华多·加莱亚诺的世界 (Chinese)

      Deutsch

      Die nicht-reformistischen Reformen von André Gorz

      Deutsch

      Als Martin Luther King seine Feuerwaffen aufgab

      Deutsch

      Mikrokredite: Die Entlassung eines Nobelpreisträgers

      Deutsch

      CAFTA – am besten stillschweigend beerdigen

      Deutsch

      Bush in Mexiko

      Deutsch

      Das globale Duell in Evian

      Deutsch

      Die Rückkehr des Daniel Ortega

      Español

      Hacer Que Nuestras Demandas Sean Tanto Orácticas Como…

      Español

      Las reformas no reformistas de André Gorz

      Español

      ¿Adoptará el nuevo papa la teología de la…

      Español

      Wall Street quiere que les estemos agradecidos

      Español

      Si Las Monjas Se Fueran a una Huelga,…

      Español

      ALEC retrocede; a la derecha le da un…

      Español

      ¿ALEC disgustado ante la pérdida de patrocinadores? Se…

      Español

      La vida en la nación prisión

      Français

      La révolution non-violente a-t-elle échoué en Egypte?

      Français

      Le pari risqué du populisme au Pérou

      Français

      Hong Kong Phooey

      Français

      Bush Nuit Même Aux Compagnies U.S.

      Français

      Le dynamisme du mouvement pour la paix

      Français

      La déroute de l’ALCA dans une Miami en…

      Français

      Ceux qui ne comptent pas

      Français

      La guerre en Irak : une expo des…

      Italiano

      C’è più di un modo per colpire il…

      Italiano

      Richieste dei movimenti: sia pratiche che visionarie

      Italiano

      La strategia di Gandhi per il successo –…

      Italiano

      Le promesse infrante di Obama

      Italiano

      Guantanamo deve sparire

      Italiano

      IL BANK TRANSFER DAY: UN SUCCESSO

      Italiano

      Come il movimento Occupiamo Wall Street si sta…

      Italiano

      Economia tabù

      Japanese

      ガンジーはどのように勝利したのか? (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Truth Versus Superpower (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Bush’s Bad Business Empire (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Revenge of the Combat Cartoonist (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Bush’s Uneasy Mexican Visita (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Mark Twain in Iraq (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Globalization’s “Lost Decade” (Japanese)

      Japanese

      Hawks Say the Damnedest Things (Japanese)

      Português

      As reformas não reformistas de André Gorz mostram…

      Português

      A vida na Nação Prisão

      Português

      Outro pretexto?

      Português

      Imigração tem efeito positivo sobre emprego e salários

      Português

      O império hipotecado

      Arabic

      Abandoning the World Bank (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      The Return of Daniel Ortega (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      Where’s The Jubilee? (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      The Last Porto Alegre (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      Seattle At Five (in Arabic)

      Arabic

      Is Market Access the Answer to Poverty? (in…

      Arabic

      Mexico’s Democratic Transition Still Incomplete (in Arabic)

      Thai

      Progressive Good Tidings of 2007 (in Thai)

      Thai

      2006: A Global Justice Year in Review (In…

      Thai

      WTO: Best Left For Dead? (In Thai)

      Thai

      Is Market Access the Answer to Poverty? (In…

      Thai

      Bush’s Bad Business Empire (In Thai)

      Thai

      The Last Porto Alegre [Thai]

      Thai

      Globalizers, Neocons, or… ? (in Thai)

      Chinese

      泛美洲人 爱德华多·加莱亚诺的世界 (Chinese)

      Chinese

      Why Wendell Matters (in Chinese)

      Chinese

      Globalization’s Watchdogs (in Chinese)

    • Other Translations
  • Appearances
  • Archive
    • 2023-2025
    • 2021-2022
    • 2019-2020
    • 2017-2018
    • 2015-2016
    • 2013-2014
    • 2011-2012
    • 2009-2010
    • 2007-2008
    • 2005-2006
    • 2003-2004
    • 1999-2002
Book ReviewsEssays / First Person1999-2002

The Sideshow Rebels

by Mark Engler September 5, 2002
written by Mark Engler September 5, 2002
The Sideshow Rebels

A review of Sideshow, USA by Rachel Adams and Jay’s Journal of Anomalies by Ricky Jay.

Published on PopPolitics.com.


A few years ago, I lived in south Florida and often hung out at a house that served as the hub for the area anarchist community. One week a man named Peter, who worked as a trainer at the Ruckus Society’s direct action skill-building camps, demonstrated for all of us how he could shove a very long nail up his nose. Tilting his head far back, he slid the spike into his nostril and toward his brain. Then, using a hammer, he tapped at the nail’s head, nudging it a few inches further than it had gone when pushed only by his extended thumb.

It’s not a “trick,” he explained, but rather an “act,” a demonstration of what unexpected things you could do with your body. To my amazement the other activists, perhaps responding to the generally participatory atmosphere of the gathering, lined up to try it themselves. Peter happily provided pointers.

My younger brother, Paul, now a union organizer, worked professionally as a juggler in his adolescence. His most popular stunt involved balancing a 10-speed bicycle on his chin. Of Peter’s work, Paul commented: “He’s not a master violinist or anything, but that takes some serious guts.” He then added, “Fire breathing is also big in punk culture.”

These anecdotal examples, of course, do not prove any deep link between radicalism and the sideshow arts. Then again, amongst my generation’s counter-cultural leftists, an interest in freakish performance turns up often enough to make me curious. (I recently learned the Lesbian Avengers also teach their members that fire eating is a good way of symbolically expressing resistance.) Feeling no inclination to perform such feats myself, I wonder about the genre: What is its appeal? What are its politics?

Two recent books, one an academic study and one a collection of historical essays by an enthusiast-insider, help to provide answers. By revealing different connections to the subject of the sideshow, the authors suggest different motivations for a political response.

The first book focuses on subversion. In her recently released Sideshow U.S.A., Rachel Adams recalls how misfit youth of the 1960s first adopted the persona, or at least the designation, of “freak” as part of a “purposeful embrace of marginality.” They did so to the great dismay of their parents, for whom the word recalled guilty memories of an exploitative and engrossing medium — the “freak show” display of “midgets, fat ladies, and wild men” — that by the 1950s had been widely denounced as sleazy and disreputable.

Nevertheless, Adams argues, the term was ripe for appropriation because “freak,” like “queer,” refers not to a specific thing, but rather to a violation of social norms. At different points in the sideshow’s history, an otherwise unexceptional woman could be exhibited alongside snake charmers and conjoined twins simply for having grown her hair long enough to reach past her knees. By the ’60s, the usefulness of such a malleable idea had become apparent to youthful rebels. Even as somber authorities increasingly moved the display of unusual bodies into the confines of medical pathology, a new generation highlighted how freaks, in a social context, are “made, not born.”

The wider argument of Sideshow, U.S.A. is that as the freak show went out of business, its imagery spread through literature, film and the visual arts. Or, more laboriously: “As actual freak shows were evicted from popular culture, their representational currency multiplied, granting them symbolic importance in inverse proportion to their declining status as a profitable mode of live entertainment.” This statement of the thesis gives fair insight into book’s content: It is an interesting and suggestive proposal, wrought in the language of professors.

To back her claim, Adams takes an in-depth look at a handful of 20th-century instances in which “freak shows performed important cultural work by allowing ordinary people to confront, and master, the most extreme and terrifying forms of Otherness they could imagine, from exotic dark-skinned people, to victims of war and disease, to ambiguously sexed bodies.”

She notes that in 1905, a black man from Africa was displayed in the Monkey House at the Bronx Zoo. The director, who considered himself a man of science, refused to admit that racism might be involved: “I am a believer in Darwinian theory,” the zoo executive explained, “but I hope my colored brethren will not take the absurd position that I am giving the exhibition to show the close analogy of the African savage to the apes.”

In the 1930s, the appearance of disabled actors in the studio cafeteria during the filming of the Tod Browning’s Freaks made screenwriter F. Scott Fitzgerald so queasy as to lose his lunch in the MGM lot. Popular audiences responded similarly when the movie hit theaters. Thus, it is not surprising that many elders recoiled when such emerging icons as Jimmy Hendrix and Frank Zappa began letting their “freak flags” fly, claiming a term that referred primarily to extreme physical difference and extending it to cover the counterculture’s brand of personal alienation. (Zappa’s 1966 debut album with The Mothers of Invention was titled Freakout!; “Hungry Freaks, Daddy” was its opening track. Meanwhile, Hendrix’s 1967 “If 6 Was 9” immortalized the image of a “freak flag” flying over a hippie nation.)

Several such examples of “freaks” appearing in popular culture are skillfully explored by Adams. But her prolonged analyses of particular works also reveal her as a miniaturist — a close reader — working a highly specialized turf. In Adams’s hands, Browning’s Freaks, Diane Arbus’s photographs, and the lesser-known books of Carson McCullers all prove to be examples loaded with social and political connotations. But in trying to hold the attention of the general reader, she struggles against the fact that none of these has attracted much more than a cult following.

Before launching a chapter based around the carnival scene, she notes that “few readers of Toni Morrison’s Beloved recall that early in the novel Sethe, Denver, and Paul D visit a carnival freak show.” The author may make a genuinely insightful case for the potential significance of the obscure moment. Few readers of Sideshow, U.S.A., however, will agree that such artifacts do much to establish the “centrality of the freak show” in the “literary and visual culture of the past century.”

But even if Adams falls short of sustaining such a bold argument, and even if we accept the traditional freak show as a form that increasingly fades from memory, the author demonstrates in conclusion that the few sideshows that have reappeared today have remade themselves as venues for subversive politics. For example, Jennifer Miller, “a woman with a beard,” attacks gender norms in her Coney Island monologues, bonding with women who begrudge waxing and electrolysis. The queer performance troupe that she leads, Circus Amok, uses campy antics to enact a well-known skit demonstrating the maldistribution of wealth in the country: While one person stretches out leisurely to cover half of the folding chairs in a row of 10, the nine remaining actors pile upon the few seats that remain.

A second recent book on unusual entertainments, Jay’s Journal of Anomalies, moves in a different direction, focusing more on the performers’ craft than their audiences’ response. Rachel Adams may admit to being not only a critic, but also a fan of the contemporary sideshow. Nevertheless, historian Ricky Jay remains more deeply implicated in the genre. Once the youngest magician ever to appear on TV (at age 7), Jay went on to share the stage with “mediocre midget accordion players, splendid soap-bubble blowers, and Japanese quick-change artists.” An accomplished sleight-of-hand artist, he gained renown for his skill with playing cards — for hurling them into the husk of a watermelon, or for clearing distances of up to 198 feet with a mighty flick of the wrist.

He subsequently produced books with such alluring titles as Cards As Weapons and Learned Pigs and Fireproof Women. The latter revealed a serious scholarly streak. It contained erudite essays on the history of various eccentricities, from armless calligraphy to the origins of modern mind reading. Through the mid-1990s, Jay, while expanding his activity to include film work with David Mamet, continued producing historical reviews. With a fine press newsletter, the original Jay’s Journal of Anomalies, he distributed quarterly examinations of unusual entertainments that have evolved through the last four centuries. The new book collects 16 issues of the journal into a volume that is itself an anomaly: printed on creamy paper and filled with rare images from Jay’s personal collection of carnival publicity.

The book is instantly delightful. An opening passage describes the career of one of history’s most successful canine performers: “In an era rich in examples of animal scholarship, Munito was a star.” The article goes on to relate how the talented dog’s repertoire of doing long division and answering bookish inquiries with alphabet cards was stolen — such is the way of show business — by other hounds (or at least by their trainers). Even Houdini presented an act, “Bobby, the Handcuff Dog,” lifted from an earlier canine master.

Like Adams, Ricky Jay shows that the histories of science and hucksterism have frequently co-mingled. In the late 1700s, a performer-cum-scientist in the court of Maria Theresa displayed a wooden automaton seated at a gear-filled cabinet. After being wound up, the wooden man capably challenged royal patrons in chess matches. Unlike the inventor’s legitimate innovations in the mechanical replication of human speech, the illusion (actually powered by a human conspirator concealed amongst the gears) grew quickly famous. Although it had many debunkers, Edgar Allan Poe among them, the automaton chess man played to great acclaim on both sides of the Atlantic.

But more fascinating than the hoax itself is the fact that the improbable invention inspired others to much greater feats of industrial revolution. Upon hearing of a robot that could “make all the variety of moves required in that complicated game,” the Rev. Edmund Cartwright insisted that certainly he could make the breakthrough power loom that he had conceptualized in his dreams. And so he did.

Many of the acts that Jay explores have shown surprising resiliency. On-stage human crucifixion has a long history, and it continued at least through the mid-20th century, proving too painful for the gathered community at the Abbott’s 1955 Magic Get-Together to watch. After looking back at their Enlightenment-era predecessors, Jay traces a lineage of contemporary face-makers to Jim Carrey, and finds modern-day ceiling walkers in Stanley Kubrick’s 2001 and in the art house films of Matthew Barney.

By looking at a field not wholly subsumed by the “Other” on display, Jay breaks down the dichotomy between the performer and the “born freak.” Explaining his approach to the subject, Jay writes: “While I have long written about anomalies, in dimension as well as deed, I have traditionally placed more emphasis on prowess than physical exaltation. Siamese twins, for instance, were worthy of discussion only if balanced on their heads, reciting Goliardic verse and providing their own accompaniment on violin and dulcimer.”

Jay’s motivation in his study is clearly not that of the dissertation writer. He closes his book with an unabashed exclamation, “I really do love this stuff!” And with his wry comments on fellow entertainers’ acts, he conveys a deep solidarity — giving the impression that at any moment he, like my activist friends in Florida, may be the next to try.

This enthusiasm fits with a time when exploitation of deformity no longer provides a reliable source of income, and when the sideshow turns to performance art and street theater. It reveals that in freakishness, broadly defined, there resides something beyond the possibility of subverting culturally enforced norms. In Ricky Jay’s work, one also finds a celebration of human potential — a delight in those who, by demonstrating what unusual things they could do with their bodies, were able to evoke awe and sometimes even to improve their lot in life.

Maybe it’s not so strange to suggest that, as much as expressing deviance, those who take up unusual acts may also be exhibiting a drive to self-improvement. But it is interesting to consider whether this drive — which stands among the most American impulses in politics — has penetrated the do-it-yourself ethos of contemporary anarchism. And whether it might even afflict our punks.

Mark Engler

Mark Engler is a writer based in Philadelphia and an editorial board member at Dissent magazine. His latest book, written with Paul Engler, is entitled This Is an Uprising: How Nonviolent Revolt Is Shaping the Twenty-First Century.

previous post
Basta NAFTA y CAFTA!
next post
Public Costs, Private Gains: Enron in Guatemala

You may also like

The Pan American

August 13, 2018

The Godfather of Microcredit

October 1, 2009

Capitalism as Catastrophe

March 31, 2008

Is Rambo Still A Republican?

November 1, 2004

Four Ways of Looking at an Aztec Eagle

June 1, 2010

The Ascent of Niall Ferguson

March 17, 2009

Ordinary Outrages

April 24, 2002

On the Price is Right

October 1, 2001

The Last Porto Alegre

February 14, 2005

No Better Place

February 28, 2005

Subscribe

Sign up to receive new articles and essays by email via our Substack newsletter, "Dispatches from the Whirlwind":

The Author

Mark Engler is a writer based in Philadelphia and an editorial board member at Dissent magazine. His latest book, written with Paul Engler, is entitled This Is an Uprising: How Nonviolent Revolt Is Shaping the Twenty-First Century (Nation Books). Mark’s full bio is available here.

Latest Articles

  • Could we be entering a ‘movement moment’ against Trump?

    April 10, 2025
  • Trump’s backpedaling shows he’s not invincible

    March 19, 2025
  • It’s going to take multiple strategies to win under Trump 2.0

    January 31, 2025
  • A new wave of movements against Trumpism is coming

    November 9, 2024
  • How to make sure your disruptive protest helps your cause

    August 9, 2024

Mark’s Articles Appear In:

  • Dissent
  • The Nation
  • The New Republic
  • N+1
  • Salon.com
  • The Los Angeles Times
  • Waging Nonviolence
  • Boston Review
  • The Atlantic
  • Rolling Stone
  • The Guardian
  • In These Times
  • TomDispatch
  • New Internationalist
  • Yes! Magazine
  • Audubon Magazine
  • Jacobin
  • Mother Jones
  • Le Monde diplomatique
  • Grist Magazine
  • Rebelión
  • The San Francisco Chronicle
  • The Progressive
  • Newsday
  • openDemocracy
  • Truthout
  • Christian Science Monitor
  • Dollars & Sense
  • Progreso Semanal
  • Chicago Reader
  • Sin Permiso
  • Baltimore Sun
  • The Ecologist
  • TruthDig
  • Asia Times
  • Sierra Magazine
  • Labor Notes
  • New Politics
  • The Catholic Worker
  • The Des Moines Register
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email

Back To Top